The thing that matters when you choose a CEO coach is evidence they have sat with someone carrying the weight you are carrying. Accreditation tells you they were trained. It tells you nothing about that.
I write this as someone who would like you to hire me, so read it with that in mind. But I have also told plenty of CEOs they didn't need a coach, and that's in here too.
A logo wall is not evidence. A company can appear on a coach's site because they ran a workshop for forty middle managers in one division.
So ask about the person, not the company. Who was the individual, what was happening to them, and what was the coach doing while it happened? A coach who has worked at this level will answer with a situation. One who hasn't will answer with a methodology.
Here's the thing nobody tells you: the step up to CEO changes the work more than any step before it. A coach who is good with senior leaders is not automatically good with a CEO, because the problems that reach a CEO have already defeated everyone else. If their experience stops two levels below you, you'll be paying them to learn.
Six, and what a real answer sounds like.
Who have you worked with in a situation like mine, and what happened? You want a specific account with the company anonymised. Vagueness here is the answer.
What will you do in the first month? A good answer involves talking to people who are not you. If the whole engagement is conversations with you, it's a series of conversations.
Who else will you speak to, and what comes back to me? This should be settled before anything starts, and so should the reverse.
If my company is paying, what goes back to HR or the board? Get this in writing. It goes wrong more often than anything else in a sponsored engagement, and it goes wrong late.
What does finished look like? If there's no answer, the engagement will run until the budget stops.
Tell me about one that didn't work. Everyone has one. How they talk about it tells you more than anything else they'll say that hour.
An ICF or EMCC credential means supervised hours, a code of ethics and someone checking their practice. That's worth something. It's a floor.
What it doesn't tell you is whether they can hold a room with a CEO in it. Some of the best people at this level came out of operating roles and never collected a credential. Some heavily accredited coaches have never worked above divisional leadership.
So use accreditation to rule out the unserious. Don't use it to choose.
Ask for a CEO, not a chief people officer. The CHRO bought the service. The CEO received it.
Then ask three things. What changed that you could point to? What would you have changed about how it ran? Would you use them again for something harder than that?
That last question does the work. A polite reference answers yes to the first two and hesitates on the third.
Before you compare two proposals, check they describe the same thing. At this level the engagement should include:
If a proposal has none of that, you're buying conversation. Conversation has value. It isn't the same purchase.
A psychometric as the centrepiece. Assessments are useful inputs. An engagement built around debriefing one is a product.
Unbounded scope. No end date and no stated outcome means both sides are guessing, and the one who's guessing with their own money is you.
Confidentiality you can't verify. See the question above about what goes back to the board.
Learning your industry on your time. Nobody needs to know your sector from the inside to coach you well. But if the first six weeks are a tutorial, you're funding their education.
Three situations where I'd tell you not to bother.
When the problem is structural. If the operating model is broken, or two of your executives can't work together, coaching you will not fix it and will delay the decision that would. Actually, let me put that more plainly: it'll give you something to do instead of the thing you're avoiding.
When you haven't chosen it. An engagement your board or your CHRO has arranged for a CEO who doesn't want it produces polite sessions and nothing else. Everyone can tell, including you.
When what you need is information. Sometimes the answer is a sector expert, a lawyer, or someone who has done the specific transaction before. Good coaches say so in the first conversation. Ask directly and watch what happens.
Everything above is a question you can put to me. The first conversation costs nothing, and if I'm the wrong person for your situation I'll say so in it.
Insider strategies in your inbox every Thursday